My answers change every year. (Technically the question changes every year, too. In the 80s we said 'records' or 'cassettes' in the 90s we said CDs and now we say iPod/MP3. Who knows what's next?)
So way back when during the 80s I would've said:
Then came the 90s and my list changed slightly.
- Staind Chapter V (plus a bonus song from another album because it's one of my faves ever and I can't imagine being stranded without being able to listen to It's Been Awhile
- The Catch and Release Soundtrack
- Buckcherry 15
What three albums would you take to the island with you today? Were they different 10 years ago?