Showing posts with label teen drinking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label teen drinking. Show all posts

Thursday, August 21, 2008

"If I Can Die in a War, Why Can't I Buy a Beer?"

As college freshman leave home this week, presidents from 100 of the nation's best-known universities, including Duke, Johns Hopkins, Syracuse, Tufts, and Ohio State, are asking lawmakers to lower the nation's drinking ages (ages, plural...drinking age is a state issue, although every state in the country has adopted the age-21 requirement or face losing 10% of its federal highway funding) from 21 to 18.

Many groups, such as Mothers Against Drunk Driving, oppose this measure, saying it encourages binge drinking and will lead to more fatal crashes.

I disagree. In fact, I think it will be the exact opposite, and I applaud the college presidents for taking the lead.

We've previously discussed this in a roundabout way when Gwen said she occasionally allows her kids wine with dinner:
http://fictionistas.blogspot.com/2008/04/but-all-european-parents-are-doing-it.html

In countries where the drinking age is 18, 16, or even no drinking age at all, teenagers are exposed to alcohol at a much earlier age by having a glass of wine at dinner with their parents. It's just a normal part of life, so when they go off to college or get to the legal drinking age, it's no big deal. They don't feel any pressure to binge drink because it's just alcohol.

In the US, however, we treat alcohol as a taboo. And teens love taboos. Let's face it...teens love to rebel. If you say something's off-limits, they'll immediately gravitate towards it.

So if you're at a party where the booze is flowing, you'll drink. And drink. And drink. Who knows when the next time is that you'll get to drink, so you overdo it. And because you can't drink at home or in a safe environment, you end up having to drive afterwards.

Same thing with college. Once campuses started really cracking down on underage drinking, it was pushed off-campus. Why do you think the Duke lacrosse players were at an off-campus house the night of that ill-fated stripper party? Because they couldn't drink on campus. And when you push drinking off-campus, you inadvertantly force students to drive. (Yes, I know they could call cabs. That's not the issue here. The issue is off-campus vs. on-campus.)

Lower the drinking age, and you'll bring alcohol back to campus. Social life will return to campus, and students won't have to drive. They can just walk back to their dorm.

Lower the drinking age, and students won't feel the need to binge drink. We're one of the only countries in the world with a binge-drinking problem among teens and college students. Why is that? Well, I think it's because of our high legal drinking age.

When something's illegal, you tend to overindulge in it, for fear that you won't get to do it ever again. But if it's just a normal part of life (like how alcohol is treated in many other countries, particularly in Europe), then you don't feel any need to binge.

So I applaud these college presidents for a common sense solution to a problem and hope that lawmakers follow suit. And even if the drinking age doesn't get lowered, at least the president have started a dialogue and hopefully other solutions will be offered as well.

I know my opinion won't necessarily be popular amongst parents (although it will be amongst teens), but that's OK. So what do you think about binge drinking and drunk driving? Do you think the drinking age should be lowered? Raised? Left the same? Did your parents let you drink as a teen? Dish!

Friday, April 11, 2008

But all the European parents are doing it...






My kids have never seen me drunk.
Though they have seen me drink.

I recently came across a parenting blog that completely condemned a practice I have condoned on an infrequent basis. And I was a little miffed, frankly.


Horror of horrors...I allow my daughter sips of wine at dinner. She had a mimosa at a shower once (I made it, it wasn't very strong). My thinking is that wine, like say...brownies, is a really nice accompaniment to a good meal or a celebration. To carry on the metaphor I would stay away from eating the whole pan of brownies--it will make you sick. Enjoy the brownie but don't overindulge. If you find yourself doing or saying things you normally wouldn't when you eat brownies, then you are eating too many.
Yes?


I see the point the non-sippers are trying to make. Alcoholism is dangerous and rampant among teens. You know what else is dangerous?


Cars.


But as good parents, we take them out driving, don't we? We supervise them, give them advice, teach them the do's and don'ts of the road....proper car ettiquette. It isn't like we pick the magic number of 16 and hand them the keys and say--okay now you're ready since it's your birthday. I realize that you've never been behind the wheel, but you'll be fine because you are older today than you were yesterday.

My feeling is that I am not raising children, I am raising adults. I need my daughter to be ready to make informed decisions when I'm not around. By witnessing and taking part in responsible drinking behavior, I'm hoping to avoid the three a.m. cleaning up vomit on her bedroom floor ritual (I won't tell you which of my friend's did that to her mom when we were teens).

But...I understand the flip side too. I encourage her to be sexually abstinent but allow her to try my Peppermint Patty in front of the fireplace after it snows. Am I giving her mixed signals?

So what are your feelings? Am I wearing rosé-colored glasses?
(and wasn't that a cute pun?)